Written by Jerry Mayer
Directed by Evelyn Rudie
Out-of-work adman Josh (Kip Gilman) isn’t the first person to swear at Will Shortz. For over 20 years, the wickedly clever cruciverbalist has challenged and confounded those brave enough to enter the daunting intellectual thicket known as The New York Times Crossword Puzzle. Like many puzzle enthusiasts, Josh gets a few clues right, then finds the whole enterprise too daunting and gives up. Not so with circumspect psychologist Janet (Andrea McArdle). In her view, a quitter never wins.
The two discover each other’s differences – and a few surprising commonalities- during a chance encounter on a Bay Area Rapid Transit train. It’s early morning and there are no other passengers in their car. Janet’s lost in her own troubled thoughts, but given their shared penchant for puzzles, and Josh’s innate yenta-like nature, the two soon get to talking. Significantly, Janet does the crossword with a pen, carefully thinking her answers through before making a mark. Josh jots things down in pencil, believing errors can always be rectified. Opposites attract, but Janet is understandably hesitant to jump into a relationship with a total stranger. This leaves Josh with the challenge of winning her over in only ten or so BART train stops. If he reads the clues carefully, he just might have a chance.
Given the show’s constraints of time and space, it’s only natural that a few contrivances are needed in order to steer the story to its destination. Yet the exposition rarely feels forced, and the characters have more dimension than the romcom cliches that usually accompany this type of premise. Playwright Jerry Mayer endows Janet and Josh with complicated lives, and the script touches, albeit lightly, on real issues like career regret and strained familial relationships. Direcor Evelyn Rudie keeps the action flowing convincingly in confining space of the subway car, while Gilman and McCardle bring buoyancy and charm even to the play’s more somber beats. The production’s only major problem is technical one: the actors are miked in a way that feels tinny and artificial. Amplification is a necessary evil in today’s theater, but in a naturalistic presentation, the audience should never be aware of it.
2 ACROSS continues in an open run at St. Luke’s Theatre , 308 West 46th Street (between 8th and 9th Avenues). Tickets, Telecharge.com